Thesis Eleven current issue

Introduction

Roberts, D. — Mon, 27 Jul 2009 08:46:18 PDT

Tragedy, Theodicy and 9/11: Rhetorical Responses To Suffering and Their Public Significance

Pirro, R. — Mon, 27 Jul 2009 08:46:18 PDT

Two general sorts of responses to the suffering caused by the 9/11 attacks are distinguishable in the statements of public officials, journalists, and citizens: one manifests a tragic sensibility, another takes the form of theodicy. Each response entails a distinctive set of expectations about the nature of political agency and solidarity in a democracy. With its claim of access to a transcendental form of truth, theodicy promises a robust sense of political solidarity and agency based on a shared religious belief. Tragic modes of appeal muster their consolatory effects by appealing to intuitions or taste rather than religious belief and therefore potentially remain open to more diverse public audiences.

Revising Foucault's Model of Modernity and Exclusion: Gauchet and Swain On Madness and Democracy

Weymans, W. — Mon, 27 Jul 2009 08:46:18 PDT

This article reveals how Marcel Gauchet and his late wife Gladys Swain revise Foucault's history of madness and modernity by arguing that the history of modern civilization represents a recognition of the mad, rather than their exclusion. Turning to the French Revolution, the article then examines the relationship between disciplinary practices and a wider democratic context. It shows that while Foucault reduces democratic societies to proto totalitarian practices, Gauchet and Swain give a broader and more historically complex account of asylums and the democratic context in which they emerge. This allows them to see resistance in the asylum and in democratic societies in general: while Foucault thought the panoptic asylum revealed modernity's ultimate success, for Gauchet and Swain it proved only its failure. However, the article ends by arguing that, despite all their differences, Gauchet and Swain's critique of contemporary societies remains in some respects indebted to Foucault.

'Messianicity' in Social Theory? A Critique of a Thesis of Jacques Derrida

Harrington, A. — Mon, 27 Jul 2009 08:46:18 PDT

Jacques Derrida's vision of 'messianicity' in his book Specters of Marx and the essay 'Faith and Knowledge: The Two Sources of "Religion" at the Limits of Reason Alone' has been widely appreciated by scholars. Yet little fundamentally critical engagement appears to have been made with some important historical-sociological questions raised by Derrida's ideas in these texts. Drawing on earlier reference-points in 20th-century critical theory and sociology, the present article argues for some objections to Derrida's presentation of the significance of religious messianism in modern Western social and political thought. The central claim defended is that Derrida invidiously marginalizes some important non-messianistic idioms, sources and traditions of thinking about religious history and its bearing on contemporary social and political self-understanding.

What Is Work? Key Insights From the Psychodynamics of Work

Deranty, J.-P. — Mon, 27 Jul 2009 08:46:18 PDT

This article aims to present some of the main results of contemporary French psychodynamics of work. The writings of Christophe Dejours constitute the central references in this area. His psychoanalytical approach, which is initially concerned with the impact of contemporary work practices on individual health, has implications that go well beyond the narrow psycho-pathological interest. The most significant theoretical development to have come out of Dejours's research is that of Yves Clot, whose writings will constitute the second reference point in this article. The article attempts to demonstrate that the thick definition of work that Dejours and Clot operate with, as a result of their focus on its psychological function, speaks directly, in substantial and critical ways, to all disciplines with an interest in work, to philosophers, social theorists and social scientists, including economic theorists.

Labour Migration and Ties of Relatedness: Diasporic Houses and Investments in Memory in a Rural Philippine Village

Aguilar, F. — Mon, 27 Jul 2009 08:46:18 PDT

Putting migrant remittances into house construction and rebuilding is generally seen as either conspicuous consumption or productive investment, but in both cases the perspective is economistic. This article argues that only when the cultural dimension of economic action is understood will it be possible to comprehend migrant spending on houses. Specifically, this article seeks to understand why, in the case of the rural Tagalog village in this study, located in upland Batangas Province in the Philippines, overseas labour migrants build houses that they do not even live in, but are given to parents or simply left unoccupied. The explanation is framed in relation to the meanings of houses in a culture of bilateral kinship, which the Philippines shares with most parts of Southeast Asia, but inflected by distinct colonial influences. The article demonstrates the ways in which houses as memorials serve as idioms of ties of relatedness within kin groups and the broader community, ties that are being transformed by global migration and experienced differently yet maintained, renegotiated yet sustained transnationally.

Socialism and Culture: An Interview With Donald Sassoon

Beilharz, P. — Mon, 27 Jul 2009 08:46:18 PDT

For Marx and Marxism: An Interview With Kostas Axelos

Memos, C. — Mon, 27 Jul 2009 08:46:18 PDT

Anticipating Obama: An Interview With Zygmunt Bauman

Battiston, G. — Mon, 27 Jul 2009 08:46:18 PDT

Reviews: Sian Supski, It Was Another Skin: The Kitchen in 1950s Western Australia (Peter Lang, 2007)

Duruz, J. — Mon, 27 Jul 2009 08:46:18 PDT

Reviews: Elemer Hankiss, The Toothpaste of Immortality: Self-Construction in the Consumer Age (Johns Hopkins University Press, 2006)

Wright, K. — Mon, 27 Jul 2009 08:46:18 PDT